Error message

Deprecated function: The each() function is deprecated. This message will be suppressed on further calls in menu_set_active_trail() (line 2405 of /mnt/stor2-wc1-dfw1/373303/427805/www.marciaforbes.com/web/content/includes/menu.inc).

Women Performed Well in Jamaica’s 2011 Elections

Marcia Forbes PhD

In the recently concluded elections the two major political parties in Jamaica, the People’s National Party (PNP) and the Jamaica Labour Party (JLP), fielded a total of 19 women, six by the PNP and 13 by the JLP. At the end of vote-counting five of the PNP’s six have been victorious. This includes the party leader Mrs Portia Simpson Miller. Only three of the JLP’s 13 will take a seat in Parliament. Interestingly these three, all very close to or over 60 years of age, are seasoned politicians. They’ve won their seats before. None of the new ‘young’ women in the JLP made it through.

Context is everything, though. The performance of the 19 women must be analysed against a backdrop of a massive landslide victory for the PNP not anticipated by many coupled with low voter turnout at 52.6%, the lowest in recent history. Of the six PNP candidates, three were sitting members of parliament (Simpson-Miller, Hannah, Neita-Headley). Three (Daley, Ffolkes-Abrahams, Philips) were brand new to the process. Daley could be seen as having been handed a ‘safe seat’. She went up against Haye-Webster, her former colleague and mentor who, having won that constituency for several years, only weeks before the elections and after sitting as an independent MP for some months, crossed the floor of parliament in support of the JLP. What of the other two new PNP female candidates?
Philips, a young woman, was put up against the wily, crafty old JLP politician, Karl Samuda, who has won that constituency for more times than many can remember. He did so even when he fell out with the JLP and switched to the PNP. He continued winning when he returned to the JLP. No one expected Philips to win and she did not. Folkes-Abrahams, recently returned to Jamaica from living overseas, reportedly had strong campaign support from former Prime Minister, PJ Patterson. The St. James West Central seat which she won was always ‘shaky’ for the JLP’s Clive Mullings, originally a PNP supporter who switched to the JLP. PJ Patterson would know this. He seems to have worked Mullings’s weaknesses to maximum advantage for Folkes-Abrahams.

Women now comprise 12 per cent of the PNP’s 42 seats in Parliament. For the JLP with only 21 seats, women account for approximately 15 per cent. Coming back to the 13 fielded by that party, what went wrong for most of them? They came to the national elections on a strong tide of anti-JLP sentiment fuelled by charges of botched handling of the Dudus extradition, exposure of gross mismanagement of the Jamaica Development Infrastructure Programme (JDIP - a mega-million dollar loan from the Chinese for infrastructure strengthening and which will have to be repaid), unacceptable levels of arrogance by JLP men at senior levels coupled with issues of race and class which we in Jamaica continue to ignore or undervalue to our peril. Derogatory racist and classist comments about some of the JLP female candidates were replete on social media.

More than half (7) of the JLP’s 13 females were new to running as constituency candidates. In the face of a speedily called election by a brand new Prime Minister with little time for on the ground work by these women and against a backdrop of the aforementioned conditions, it is not surprising that they did not win their seats. However, before we begin to position these women and their PNP colleague as ‘losers’ let us take the time to understand what really went down in these elections. At least seven JLP male Ministers (so far), senior and junior ones, lost their seats. Against this sobering reality note among the JLP females who did not win their seats many were defeated by narrow margins - Gordon-Webley 49% to Crawford’s 50%, Charles-Freeman’s 48% to Ferguson’s 51%, Longmore’s 49% to Hylton’s 51% and Kerr-Jarrett’s 49% to Duncan’s 51%. No one in Jamaica expected the JLP females to win against Peter Phillips, Ronnie Thwaites, Roger Clarke or Robert Pickersgill, crafty old PNP male politicians, steeped in the wiles of representational politics.

The JLP women who were there prior to the addition of the recent ones ALL won their seats. Olivia ‘Babsy’ Grange and Shahine Robinson, former Cabinet Ministers, as well as Marissa Dalrymple-Philibert, former Speaker of the House, have retained their seats. This must say something about the ability of women in politics and certainly too the fact that five out of the six female candidates fielded by the PNP won their seats. One could examine the criteria used by the JLP in its selection of the woman who ran but that’s another article. No one expects to hear that it was simply their ‘bononoonoos’ status since the slate included lawyers, doctors and management professional, highly educated women whose value goes well beyond their physical form.

This review of the women who ran comes within the context of the 51% Coalition - Development and Empowerment Through Equity – a campaign which represents the coming together of women’s organizations and women in our individual capacity to advocate for legislative quotas to advance women’s participation in decision-making. The Coalition calls for adherence to the principle of the 60:40 quota, that is, no more than 60 and no less than 40 per cent of either sex to be immediately applied to the selection of Senators and to appointments to public sector Boards and Commissions. The 51% Coalition also calls for the effective implementation of the National Policy on Gender Equality.